Thousands protest in Dublin against removal of triple lock
Leah Farrell

Thousands protest in Dublin against removal of triple lock

The government is seeking to remove the triple lock through new legislation.

LAST UPDATE | 2 hrs ago

THOUSANDS HAVE TAKEN to the streets today in support of Irish neutrality and to protest against the plans to reform the triple lock.

Demonstrators waved Irish tricolours, alongside UN and Palestinian flags, as they protested against proposals to alter the rules governing the overseas deployment of Irish troops.

Signs were held reading: “stick your EU army up your hole”, and: “make tea not war”, while Irish senator Frances Black sang Legal Illegal, a song she said is “about the difference between what’s legal and what’s right”.

Leah Farrell

The “triple lock” is a mechanism that sets out the conditions under which more than 12 Irish troops may participate in overseas peace support operations.

For troops to take part, the operation must be mandated by the United Nations; it must be approved by the government; and it must be approved by Dáil Éireann by means of a resolution. 

The government is seeking to remove that mechanism through new legislation that is making its way through the Houses of the Oireachtas. 

Last month the Dáil voted by a narrow margin to reform the system.

The Bill, which the government aims to have enacted by the end of the year, seeks to remove the UN mandate from the legislation, in the name of preventing any of the five permanent members of the Security Council, which includes Russia and China, from exercising their veto against Irish peacekeeping missions.

Opposition parties have said the reform would damage Ireland’s commitment to neutrality, while the Government has accused opposition TDs of spreading misinformation on the topic.

Irish Senator Tom Clonan, a former peacekeeper who was deployed to southern Lebanon as an officer commanding Irish troops under the United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL), told the crowd in Dublin on Saturday: “We are at an inflection point.

“The Government have been relying on a number of talking points that are factually incorrect, and in fact it’s not misinformation; it’s disinformation, they’re trying to deceive us.

Leah Farrell

“The first one is: ‘Oh, it was in the programme for Government that we would reform the triple lock.’ They’re not reforming it, they’re not amending it – they’re getting rid of it completely, against the will of the people.

“The second one is: ‘Oh, there is no link between our neutrality and the triple lock.’ Well, that’s like saying there’s no link between the steering wheel and the brakes on your car.

“The triple lock is intimately linked to our neutrality, and it’s our brakes, because if you have Simon Harris or Micheál Martin behind the wheel, they’re going to take us away from our neutral status.”

He added: “The other myth and shameful talking point is that we want to reclaim our sovereignty, that we don’t want to allow Russia or China or the United States to decide where we send our troops.

“Again, let me be clear: Xi Jinping, Vladimir Putin, Donald Trump – they don’t even know we have an army, they don’t care where we send our army.

“It was a decision of the Irish people, a sovereign decision expressed through the Houses of the Oireachtas to be bound by the multilateral principles of the United Nations and the UN Security Council and the UN Assembly – that was a decision of the Irish people, nothing to do with foreign leaders.”

Leah Farrell

Adam Stoneman, who attended the protest, said the prospect of removing the mechanism is “a really dangerous threat to Irish neutrality”.

“I’m proud of Irish neutrality, I’m proud of that position,” he said.

“I think it served us well, and obviously it matters to my children because I don’t want them to grow up into an Ireland that’s pulled into needless war and bloodshed and diverting funds from libraries and schools and art centres towards guns and tanks and military.

“I think our neutrality has served us well. I think our focus on diplomacy over aggressive war-making is something we should be very proud of, and here today to make a stand.”

Mr Stoneman said he felt there is “no reason to undermine” Irish neutrality by scrapping the triple lock.

“The Government’s attack on the triple lock has nothing to do with Irish interests and all to do with the interests of more powerful countries like the USA and the European bloc, so, look, I think we need to be more proactive in terms of developing our neutrality.”

People Before Profit TD Richard Boyd Barrett said the Government is “selling out Irish neutrality under the feet of the people of this country”

“It is a betrayal of what this country is about, which is about opposing colonialism, opposing militarism and war,” he said.

“And the Irish Government want to drag us away from that tradition into involvement with Nato, with European militarisation, and with the sort of powers that have committed genocide against the Palestinian people and that are engaged in war mongering across the world and we oppose that, and we think the majority of Irish people oppose that.”

Some of those opposed to the Government’s plans are calling for a referendum on the triple lock, citing strong public backing for Ireland’s neutral status.

Defence minister Helen McEntee has previously said that supporters of a referendum are being misled by the opposition, as a referendum is to amend, take something out of, or add to the constitution.

At the demonstration on Saturday, Sinn Féin TD Donnchadh Ó Laoghaire said Irish people “value neutrality and want to keep it”.

“The triple lock is an essential protection for that and if the Government wants to get rid of it, given the fact that the Irish people clearly support it, there should be a referendum,” he said.

“We are never going to be a major military power, our greatest strength is as a voice for peace and diplomacy, our neutrality essential to that.”

On Friday, foreign affairs minister Helen McEntee said she will consider an amendment put forward by Fianna Fáil’s Willie O’Dea to the government’s triple lock legislation.

The veteran Limerick TD, along with nine other Fianna Fáil TDs, is supporting the proposed amendment which would require approval from the UN General Assembly, but not the Security Council, when Irish troops are being sent abroad.

With reporting by PA

View 75 comments
Comments Summary
AI-GENERATED
Readers argue whether scrapping the triple lock threatens Irish neutrality.
Where they land
Some fear losing neutrality while others argue it hinders peace.
What they think
Scrapping the mechanism risks dragging Ireland into foreign wars.
The policy has nothing to do with neutrality.
Close
75 Comments
This is YOUR comments community. Stay civil, stay constructive, stay on topic. Please familiarise yourself with our comments policy here before taking part.
Leave a Comment
Submit a report
Please choose a reason for reporting this comment. Your report will be reviewed by our moderation team
We've received your report. Thank you for helping keep our community safe and respectful.

Leave a comment cancel